Academic All-Great Lakes Valley Conference |
| Athlete(s) | Year |
| Kim Gervais | 1990 |
| Beth Lohmeier, Laura Ames, Melissa Awalt | 1991 |
| Amanda Grove, Tara Lovekamp | 1994 |
| Amanda Grove, Jean Goerling, Becky Lawton, Debbie Urban, Laura Schneeweiss | 1995 |
| Amy Hansen, Jean Goerling, Colleen Quinlan, Debbie Urban, Stephanie Soller, Mary Wright, Laura Schneeweiss | 1996 |
| Amy Hansen, Colleen Quinlan, Stephanie Soller, Mary Wright | 1997 |
| Amy Hansen, Mary Wright, Micci Brandy, Helen Kelliher, Traci West, Beth Steele, Christina Enders, Sarah Welles | 1998 |
| Micci Brandy, Helen Kelliher, Beth Steele, Christina Enders, Sarah Welles, Katie Holtz, Joy Rauch, Elisa Bott, Mary Corsten, Patty Getz, Gina Greenan, Stacy Moss | 1999 |
| Sarah Welles, Katie Holtz, Darthy Barr, Sarah Beebe, Elisa Bott, Mary Corsten, Patty Getz, Katie Gilman | 2000 |
| Katie Holtz, Elisa Bott, Mary Corsten, Joy Rauch, Stacy Moss, Katie Gilman, Brie Ruschke, Maggie Haen, Megan Poludniak | 2001 |
| Mary Corsten, Katie Gilman, Maggie Haen, Rory Harrison, Abby Hodge, Lindsay Johnson, Stacy Moss, Valerie Olis, Lisa Paasch, Megan Poludniak, Kathy Sulkowski | 2002 |
| Abby Hodge, Rory Harrison, Katie Gilman, Maggie Haen, Megan Poludniak, Lisa Paasch, Sarah McKinney, Val Olis, Melissa Dobry | 2003 |
| Sylvia Ciezak, Melissa Dobry, Lindsay Grim, Maggie Haen, Rory Harrison, Abby Hodge, Jessica Lockhart, Sarah McKinney, Andrea Morrone, Val Olis, Megan Poludniak, Michelle White | 2004 |
| Sylvia Ciezak, Melissa Dobry, Lindsay Grim, Lauren Hatter, Abby Hodge, Sarah McKinney, Andrea Morrone, Val Olis | 2005 |
| Christina Avilina, Sylvia Ciezak, Lindsay Grim, Lauren Hatter, Jaqi Kenney, Sarah McKinney, Andrea Morrone, Theresa Nugent, Kim Richards, Stephanie Sagat | 2006 |
| Christina Avilina, Sylvia Ciezak, Lauren Hatter, Jaqi Kenney, Andrea Morrone, Danielle Mount, Staci Paul, Kim Richards, Rachel Ruedi, Stephanie Sagat | 2007 |
| Katie Crawford, Hannah Koeneman, Colleen Mitros, Danielle Mount, Kim Richards, Rachel Ruedi, Stephanie Sagat, Lauren Seliga, Faith Watson | 2008 |
| Jillian Carlberg, Mary Carroll, Katie Crawford, Hannah Koeneman, Nikki Maes, Colleen Mitros, Danielle Mount, Kim Richards, Rachel Ruedi, Stephanie Sagat, Lauren Seliga, Faith Watson | 2009 |
| Jillian Carlberg, Mary Carroll, Amy Choi, Katie Crawford, Hannah Koeneman, Jennifer Krumwiede, Katherine Lindsey, Colleen Mitros, Danielle Mount, Rachel Ruedi, Faith Watson | 2010 |
| Jillian Carlberg, Mary Carroll, Amy Choi, Katie Crawford, Kelly McConkey, Colleen Mitros, Danielle Mount, Jenni Mueller, Carly Perschnick, Faith Watson | 2011 |
| Jillian Carlberg, Mary Carroll, Morgan Cebula, Amy Choi, Colleen Mitros, Jenni Mueller, Lauren O’Brien, Carly Perschnick, Vivian Pritz, Lauren Stitz, Nicole Yuede | 2012 |
| Leigh Barea, Abby Biggs, Kelly Brennan, Morgan Cebula, Amy Choi, Alexis Davito, Katie Fuerst, Ally Maurer, Jenni, Mueller, Carolyn Nojiri, Lauren O'Brien, Vivian Pritz, Jenna Selby, Maddie Seliga, Lauren Stitz, Nicole Yuede | 2013 |
